Peer review – IABS Publishing

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Name

First

Last

Title of Article Reviewed

Is the article relevant to the journal's scope?

Is the article well-written and easy to understand?

Is the article well-organized and easy to follow?

Is the article well-referenced?

Does the title accurately reflect the content of the article?

Is the abstract/introduction clear, concise, and informative?

Are the methods, results, and discission justified and presented in a clear and concise manner?

Explain your answer to the last question for any answer other than Yes.

Is there any ethical concerns with the research?

If so, do you have any suggestions for improving the article?

Do you recommend that the article be published?

If so, provide your suggestions for improving the article.